How To Store Crumbl Cookies

How To Store Crumbl Cookies

Crumbl, founded in 2017, is a cookie behemoth. They’ve already had over 300 locations across the US and are planning further expansion. When word of your excellent freshly baked product spreads across the country, more and more people are certain to have inquiries.

Storage questions for Crumbl cookies are a common one. The cookies here aren’t as good for long-term storage as their mass-produced counterparts. They’re suitable for storage at room temperature, in the fridge, or in the freezer for months. A leak-proof container is always a must. However, because of their frosted tops, you must take slightly different steps to get them ready for storage.

So, let’s talk about how to properly store Crumbl cookies right now. We will also discuss methods for extending the cookies’ shelf life and maintaining their aesthetic appeal. You may stock up on these artisanal confections this way.

What Makes Crumbl Cookies Special?

The primary characteristic that distinguishes Crumbl cookies is their exceptional freshness. Customers may observe the baking of their cookies in real time. When cookies are ordered online (through their website), they are also freshly made. In addition, the Crumbl cookies sold in their shop are never older than one day.

There are numerous additional reasons why this brand is vastly superior to others. They employ very high-quality components, which greatly improves the overall flavor of the cookie.

Additionally, the company introduces new flavors on a weekly basis to keep things exciting and prevent overstocking of cookies.

This is another method they use to prevent selling stale cookies. Plus, it enables them to bake cookies on demand! However, what we appreciate most about them are their wonderfully innovative and enjoyable cookie varieties. In addition, they are attractively ornamented!

Fried Ice Cream, Cotton Candy, Lemonade, Walnut Fudge Brownie, and Ruby Chocolate Chip are some of their most popular cookie varieties at now. In addition, they offer more traditional tastes like as Milk Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Sprinkles, Snickerdoodle, and Molten Lava!

What Makes Storing These Crumbl Cookies Difficult?

You may be asking why an entire post is devoted to these cookies. What is it about them that makes storage so difficult? The major reason these cookies require alternative storage methods is because of how they are adorned. Many of Crumbl’s cookies resemble traditional ones. Some, on the other hand, are shaped like cupcakes.

Cotton Candy Cookie, for example, is a delectable vanilla cookie topped with cream cheese icing. Instead, the Fried Ice Cream Cookie is topped with a creamy white chocolate buttercream frosting.

So, if you want these cookies to look as good after storage as they did when you first got them, you can’t just throw them in a bag or container. However, there are certain tricks you can do to keep them from squishing!

The second reason you should preserve these cookies with caution is because they are so fresh. These are practically homemade cookies — nothing like the store-bought bags!

Homemade cookies are naturally free of artificial preservatives and stabilizers. As a result, you must keep them properly to prevent them from drying out or turning stale quickly. Crumbl cookies, on the other hand, have a shorter shelf life than mass-produced cookies.

How To Store Crumbl Cookies

Therefore, you can store your cookies in three different locations: at room temperature, in the refrigerator, or in the freezer. For each, there are many ways to keep the cookies (in bags or containers). You want to keep them fresh, once more! But you probably also want to keep them looking nice.

Crumbl cookies will naturally undergo changes while stored in any of these locations, some of which will be for the better and some of which will be for the bad. But in the end, you must choose what you hope to accomplish when storing the cookies!

For instance, it’s preferable to store them at room temperature to keep them as fresh as possible. However, they won’t live very long if you do that.

While keeping them in the refrigerator will increase their shelf life, the texture will significantly change and the cookie’s crisp freshness will be lost. Both rapid and time-consuming procedures can be used to store cookies. Short-term storage is better suited to the faster techniques. For long-term storage, the longer procedures work best. Let’s take a closer look at how the various locations impact your cookies first.

How Storage Location Affects The Cookies

As a result, most individuals keep their cookies at room temperature. And just because certain Crumbl cookies are topped with frosting doesn’t mean this needs to alter. Frosted cookies, like cupcakes, stay well at room temperature. The disadvantage of storing the cookies at room temperature is that their quality degrades quickly.

Most people recommend eating your Crumbl cookies on the same day you receive them, or they won’t taste the same. Cookies can now be stored in the refrigerator to extend their shelf life. Especially if the toppings are perishable! When refrigerated in the fridge, even the frosting will stay longer.

However, as we all know, baked products can turn dry and stale in the fridge. And you can’t just pop a frosted cookie back into the oven to bring it back to life. So, before you just leave them there, consider the benefits and drawbacks. If you don’t mind minor texture changes, the fridge is the best option.

Finally, you can store your Crumble cookies in the freezer to keep them fresh for months! However, their texture and flavor will never be the same, as with all frozen goods. You have the best chance of getting a good cookie if you thaw them properly. If you don’t, your cookie will be wet, crumbly, and boring.

As a result, you may be feeling a little disheartened at this point. These are, however, worst-case possibilities. If you follow our instructions completely and use the cookies within the time frame specified, they will be nearly perfect!

Method 1: At Room Temperature

Freshly baked Crumbl cookies shouldn’t be stored at room temperature for longer than two days. After that, they’ll start to quickly lose their freshness. Many even assert that they lose some of their effectiveness after a day (though we don’t totally concur with this).

Your Crumbl cookies will be fine if you follow our storing advice for about 2-3 days. They will start to change after that, but they won’t become inedible. You probably won’t appreciate them as much after about 5 days, though they will still be edible.

Step 1: Choose Your Container

To begin, gather any form of airtight container — even zip-lock bags would suffice. Just make sure that whichever one you choose is devoid of odors and grease, as the cookies will absorb these fragrances and flavors immediately. It will eventually destroy their flavor and cause them to spoil faster. We discovered that glass containers with airtight lids perform best. They are also significantly more environmentally friendly!

Step 2: Insert Your Cookies

Next, you have two options for placing the cookies in the containers. It depends on the cookie you purchased. If you have unadorned, simple cookies, you can place them in the bag or container sideways. This is a fantastic technique to save space.

However, you must preserve frosted cookies in a single layer in the container. If you want the cookies to remain attractive (for a party or as a present), you cannot stack them vertically or horizontally. However, if you are merely storing leftover cookies and don’t care about their appearance, feel free to simply stack them.

Step 3: Store Them In A Cool, Dry Area

Now, you must keep your Crumbl cookies, of any variety (but preferably the frosted ones), in a cool, dry place. They should be kept in a dark, cool place out of the sun. In addition, you shouldn’t store them near appliances that generate heat, such as a microwave, refrigerator, or oven. Always store your container in a cold, dry place, apart from any sources of moisture.

Method 2: Inside The Fridge

Next, we will discuss storing cookies in the refrigerator. Many individuals assert that buttercream-frosted cookies must be refrigerated. This is false. Similar to buttercream-frosted cakes and cupcakes, they can be stored at room temperature without issue.

The true reason you may want to consider storing cookies in the refrigerator is if it is really hot or if you need to store them for several days. If the temperature is very high, the frosting may separate. This can cause the frosting to slip off the cookie and make it appear unappetizing.

When properly stored in the refrigerator, cookies can easily keep for up to seven days. However, keep in mind that they will not have the same texture as when they were first produced.

Step 1: Choose A Container

When storing cookies in the refrigerator, we always use an airtight container rather than zip-lock bags. Because a refrigerator is normally fairly full, the bags become crushed. So, to keep the cookies as intact as possible, use an airtight container. If you won’t be eating the cookies for a few days (or at all), wrap the container in plastic or saran wrap to make it extra airtight.

Step 2: Add Your Cookies

If you have plain cookies, you can keep them upright or stacked, just like you did for the room temperature step. However, if they are frosty and you want them to stay beautiful, put them in one container afterwards.

Each plain cookie can also optionally be wrapped in wax paper. This will stop the moisture from one object from transferring to the others. Although it is an additional step, it might prolong the cookies’ shelf life.

Step 3: Place The Cookies Inside The Fridge

Finally, seal your container and lay the cookies on top of the refrigerator. They absorb the odors and flavors of raw or cooked meat, aromatic or pungent vegetables and fruits, and open condiments. Also, if you’re going to keep them in the fridge for a while, put them in the back. The back of the refrigerator is consistently colder than the front.

Method 3: In The Freezer

For long-term storage, you can freeze these cookies for up to six months. To freeze your cookies, you must individually wrap them. The procedure is significantly more time-consuming. However, if you want them to be edible after thawing, you must keep them carefully. We suggest utilizing them within one month for optimal effects.

Step 1: Freeze The Cookies Individually

Any cookie that will be decorated with frosting or sprinkles needs to be frozen in advance. Put each cookie into a plastic bag or sealable container. Next, arrange the frosted cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet coated with parchment paper. Put them in the freezer for at least a couple of hours so the freezing process can begin.

Step 2: Place Them Inside The Container

The semi-frozen cookies should then be stacked in a big container. When freezing, frosted cookies can also be stacked on their sides. The icing will not collapse or deform under the weight of the others.

Then, shut the container’s lid. Wrap the item in aluminum foil. This foil layer will provide additional protection against freezer burn. You may label the foil with the contents if desired.

Step 3: Freeze The Cookies

Place the container in a secure part of the freezer. Unless it is made of durable plastic or glass, avoid stacking too many items on top of it.

How Long Do Crumbl Cookies Last?

In conclusion, Crumbl cookies are prepared to order and are very fresh. If you bake for the holidays, you are aware that freshly created goods don’t last as long as mass-produced ones from the shop. Therefore, these cookies will only keep at room temperature for up to 5 days, and even then, only under ideal storage conditions.

In the refrigerator, crumble cookies can last up to a week. By day 7, the cookies will taste better the less you open the jar. Finally, Crumbl cookies that have been frozen can be kept for many months. But always utilize them within a month, as we advise with all frozen foods.

How To Revive Stale Crumbl Cookies

Unless you bought basic, undecorated Crumbl cookies, they will get stale after a while. The frosted cookies will need to be taken apart and put back together before serving. Although it’s feasible, we seriously doubt that anyone would put in the effort.

If a cookie has gone stale, rebaking it is the greatest way to bring it back to life. It can be effective on occasion. But it’s your only real choice at this point.

Put the unadorned cookies on a baking sheet coated with parchment paper. Follow that up by placing them in an oven that has been preheated to 360 degrees Fahrenheit (180 degrees Celsius) for 10 to 15 minutes. This will bring out the cookies’ original crispness and intensify their flavor. After baking, give them plenty of time to cool to room temperature. You can redecorate them if you want to.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *